Medical paternalism in House M.D.

Ewa Dobrogowska shared this interesting article with us on Twitter. I didn’t think I would ever see House, M.D. in a publication:

Medical paternalism in House M.D.

Mark R Wicclair, Center for Bioethics and Health Law, University of Pittsburgh

The popular television series House M.D. is drawn upon to provide a critical examination of medical paternalism and how it is presented in the show. Dr Gregory House, the character named in the title of the series, is a paradigm of a paternalistic physician. He believes that he knows what is best for his patients, and he repeatedly disregards their wishes in order to diagnose and treat their illnesses. This paper examines several examples of medical paternalism and the means used to portray it favourably in the series. It is argued that the positive depiction of medicalpaternalism in the fictional world of the series does not apply in the real world. The paper also considers why a show that features a paternalistic physician who so blatantly flouts mainstream medical ethics might appeal to health professionals and members of the general public.

gg_hughwins_fm.jpg

Further reading: